Overall:
A friend took me to the Scotsman for dinner the other night... We were attempting to eat somewhat healthily, so we both got salads. And a bread platter. And a couple of pints.
Ordering and payment is done up front at the counter, which I quite like because it means you can just get up and go when you're done. Service was friendly and the waitresses were all quite attractive (hey, I'm single).
The Scotsman IS a tavern, and it's quite popular... so don't expect things to be overly quiet during peak times. It makes conversation a little difficult at times, but that's the norm in these types of places. The tables were fairly well spaced though, so it didn't feel overly cramped.
Anyhow, the food! The bread platter ($11) was nice - 5 or 6 slices of different breads, all lightly toasted and very tasty. It came with two dips (a beetroot one and a sundried tomato one), oil/balsamic vinegar and dukka, and butter (which was pretty much liquid when it came out, unfortunately). Perhaps one more dip would have been nice, but overall the bread platter was very nice.
The salads were damn fine. I had the Scotsman, which involves strips of lightly peppered steak (very tender and well cooked) on a salad of lettuce, cucumber, olives, tomato, beetroot (not too much, thankfully) and fetta (a generous amount) with a nice dressing - just the right amount and flavour.
My friend had the cajun chicken salad, which I snuck a taste of and it seemed rather nice - a little kick to it, but nothing overpowering.
Both salads were close to $15 each, and were well worth the price. I didn't even manage to finish mine (I think the pint and bread platter may have contributed to that)! The total bill was a shade under $60 - not exactly cheap, but still great value. Some of the meatier menu items seemed like great value - 450g steak for $28, anyone?
Wow, these reviews get longer and longer...